i woke up this morning to a tweet from esteemed senatoriable greco belgica, exhorting us to learn from the wisdom of the bible's teachings on tithing and adopt a 10% flat tax rate for the country.
it was an intriguing concept and so i decided to follow up on his idea. i clarified: "you do realize that 10% from a poor man is not the same as 10% from a rich man? how is this just?" i was surprised when the esteemed senatoriable decided to answer my question. it was the start of a lengthy conversation.
i admit that, at first blush, i was very skeptical of the viability of the flat tax. it was regressive, for one. and i was concerned of the budget shortfall that could result if we did away with all the other taxes. when the esteemed senatoriable mentioned the russian experience with flat tax, i googled it to learn more and was intrigued. apparently, how the flat tax regime fared was mixed. indeed, it led to significant improvement in voluntary tax compliance and reporting. however, the results were not as unequivocal as the esteemed senatoriable would have us believe:
While Russia’s flat tax reform has created much excitement, little solid evidence on its impact on tax evasion or the real side of the economy has been provided thus far.1 In recent research (Gorodnichenko et al., 2008), we argue that the flat tax reform was instrumental in decreasing tax evasion in Russia, and that, to a certain extent, greater fiscal revenues in 2001 and several years beyond can be linked to increased voluntary tax compliance and reporting. We also find that the productivity effect on the real side of the economy was positive, although smaller than the tax evasion effect. read more...
- It's only the poor and employees who pay the right taxes with the system we have.
- The rich avails of tax shields, tax exemptions, foundations, and expenses they put in their reports which is legally provided in the tax code to evade taxes.
- In actual practice the rich only pays less than 1% of what they ought to pay.
- The whole system discourages businesses, kaya walang trabaho at opportunity ang mga kabataan at tao dito maliban sa pulitiko.
- Change the system, n u will change the whole landscape of the economy
- Flat tax will bring ALL costs down, and increase peoples purchasing power,take home pay and ensure that everyone pays low n d right taxes. Because of its simplicity and fairness people will be more willing to pay the right taxes.
my main concern though was the math. so i asked mr. belgica whether he already made some computations on the projected government revenue from the flat tax. i felt that since he was putting forward a policy that would essentially overhaul the way this government earns its keep, the responsible thing to do was to make sure that the government would still be able to function and all existing government services would still be fully-funded.
it does not appear, however, that mr. belgica did his math. he told me that there would be an improvement of 30% in tax collection. he did not say what the base for this will be: 2012 collection? or prior years? i asked him what his basis was for saying that there would be 30% increase in tax collection. have there been studies done? the esteemed senatoriable gave me no answer. finally, i asked him: what is the basis for your 10% flat tax? i was curious if there has been any study done showing that this was the optimal amount. note that in russia, the example he cites, the payable income tax rate for individuals for 2013 is 13%.
mr. belgica said the basis for the 10% was the bible. oh well.